Right now Yahoo is my biggest search engine referral. After Yahoo there is no clear cut second place sadly. MSN, Google and Ask... yea Ask referrer about the same amount of people. Usually they refer around 50-75 a day. Yahoo referrs 500-650 a day depending on the day of the week.

On my two oldest forums, I have one that google gives me the most traffic by far, and the other one is a fairly equal split between google, yahoo, and msn.

I have submitted a reinclusion requestion for the site that isn't getting most of it's traffic from google because the forum itself gets very little search engine traffic and I think I may have been slapped on the hand by google for running coop ads for a long time.

I submitted a reinclusion request for my biggest site because of the pitiful Google referrals as well. I did this a few months ago. Still the same traffic.

Google for me, but only about 5-9% of total traffic

How many referrals does that = a day?

Google by far. Over 60,000 a day.

Wow that's awesome. I get 70 woo woo!

Very few.
.....

Maybe you guys are just using the wrong SEO hack There's something to be said about simple elegance.

It's not that I don't think. I just have made a lot of mistakes in the past with my site. I haven't been very consistent until now.